When Life Gives You Corpses by Lene D. Buttner is a quirky queer fantasy following the journey of Theory, a cursed, human-eating mantis, and Nim, an 18-year-old subpar wizard. The story alternates between Theory's first-person POV and Nim's third-person POV. I loved the word-play in the title and the unique premise and dived into the story.
Meet Theory, a cursed, human-eating praying mantis fiend who works as a search-and-recovery guide (not rescue, as he often emphasizes) at Fiendworld, a magical sinkhole turned amusement park. He hides his appearance by using glamour and supplements his meals with a finger or two from the cadavers of lost adventurers he recovers. When he is tasked against his will with rescuing a missing wizard, the son of the park's management and a descendant of the very wizard who cursed Theory, he reluctantly agrees.
To his sorrow, the wizard is still alive and insists on continuing downward with his enchanted backpack to locate his missing friend. Along the way, they encounter many dangers, such as man-eating fish, other praying mantises and fiends, and tentacle-covered walls. With the help of Cordelia (you'll find out who she is in the tale), they uncover a secret about the park and the past that will turn their world upside down.
This is one of the most original books I've read in a while. It is dark, yes, and I could do without the cannibalism. However, it isn't the focus of the story, and it serves a purpose. The book is categorized as YA, but I don't think it is appropriate for sensitive readers due to its dark and somewhat gory content. And Theory doesn't kill people to eat them. He only eats body parts from people who are already dead. Still gross, I agree.
The mystery worked well and left me intrigued. Toward the end, I guessed one of the reveals, but other twists caught me by surprise. There was also humor throughout the story, especially in the dialogue, which provided some much-needed comic relief. I loved the ending and thought it was satisfying. Admittedly, not all questions were answered, but the story stood well on its own without the answers.
Cordelia was one of my favorite secondary characters. I loved the dynamic between her and Theory and the way they communicated, as Theory was the only fiend who could speak. I also enjoyed the interactions between him and Nim, the development of their relationship, and how they both changed throughout the story. Despite his condition, Theory was the only one who understood Nim, supported him, and tried to help him see his own worth. I liked the slow-burn romance between the two and the way their relationship developed, with Theory gradually seeing Nim as less of a burden and more as a friend. And more!
Theory is a stickler for rules and regulations, hates magic, stays away from people, and keeps to himself. He is the grumpy one to Nim's sunshine. Nim is easygoing, has low self-esteem, and isn't much of a wizard. And yet, they match. I loved how Theory was able to see and understand Nim in a way that helped him recognize his own worth.
When life gives you lemons, you make lemonade. When life gives you corpses, you make a meal... The writing, world-building, and magic are unique. I loved how creative and unpredictable the world was and how I never knew what they would encounter next. Each level of the sinkhole was more dangerous than the one above. Most people only visited the upper levels, and few dared to go further down.
I loved this book immensely and highly recommend it to fans of queer enemies-to-friends-to-lovers stories, found family, and adventures. The author has created complex characters, a mysterious plot, and an extraordinary story you wouldn't want to miss.
Triggers: cannibalism, death, parental abuse, violence, body horror, gore.
* Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this arc. All opinions are my own.
* "When Life Gives You Corpses" by Lene D. Buttner









