"Her Sharp Embrace" by Kate Koenig is the first book in an original queer fantasy duology set in a New Orleans-inspired world. It started with a bang, literally, then plods along at a slower pace until just before the end, then jumps into warp speed again.
The book follows a crew of magical outlaws, the Nightshades, who fight corruption and struggle to make a living. They are Saints (magic wielders) with charisms (their powers), in a corrupt society where barons rule. Noa Toussaint is a Baroness Saint with a talent for alchemy who left her old life behind for her love of Lennon, the gang leader. The plot thickens when one of the members is murdered. The crew and the authorities are in a race to find the culprit, who seems hell-bent on destroying what’s left of the crew itself.
I had high expectations for the book based on the blurb, but I had a hard time staying engaged with the plot or connecting with the characters. The novel explores humanity, found family, betrayal, duty, class, loss, and sapphic and sisterly relationships. The concept worked for me: the magic system, the idea of a badass gang of women (Robin Hood springs to mind), the mystery at the heart of the plot, and the newspaper articles, recipes, and other excerpts woven between chapters.
The characterization of the five main characters was well done. They were flawed and human, and their backstories made them feel rounded. Each of them had a unique charism, which I loved. Sadly, except for sunny Jolie, I didn't like most of them. Noa was weak and spineless, and she kept blushing, whining, and being horny. Theo, the daughter of a pirate, was a bully, and I didn't like the way she treated Noa, or that no one really stopped her. Jolie and Lennon tried, with no success.
Both Noa and Theo irritated me with their conduct. Mei was courageous and a dark horse but didn’t really contribute much to the plot. Lennon was brave and loyal, and I loved the way she cared for her fellow gang members, whom she viewed as family. Her love for Noa made her careless and less sharp, though, which affected the entire gang.
The book alternates between past and present. The past sections are written in third-person present tense and follow multiple POVs. The “now” sections are written in the first person from Noa’s perspective. The present-tense writing didn’t work for me and felt a bit forced. The twist at the end caught me by surprise, I will give the book that. Most of the threads are resolved, with a couple of loose ends for good measure. The book ends with a small cliffhanger, which will probably be addressed in the second book.
Overall, I liked the book, so I rate it 3 out of 5 stars. There’s a lot of potential here, but it didn’t quite come together. With a bit of tightening, it could be more engaging. I will read the second book when it comes out, as I am curious how it will end. I still recommend the book to fans of morally gray characters with attitude who don't mind present-tense writing or a slower pace.
* Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this arc. All opinions are my own.
* For more info about the book: "Her Sharp Embrace" by Kate Koenig









