I have read one of Reed's books before and loved it, so I knew I was in for a great read. And I was right! "Worse Than the Others" by Mackenzie Reed is an intense YA locked-room mystery that will leave you breathless. Written in the first person and present tense, it follows an aspiring true crime YouTuber who gets drawn into investigating a year-old murder.
Meet Ames: a teenage YouTuber trying to increase her views and aspiring to become an investigative journalist. When she gets an invitation to a party at the infamous Haven Hotel, where a girl died last year, she can't resist. She saw a story about it on the internet that has since been removed, and her journalist instincts kick in. She must get to the bottom of things, even if it puts her in danger.
When she arrives at the abandoned hotel, she meets six other teens, a group of friends who received similar invitations. When one of them tries to leave, he is murdered, and a mysterious voice warns them that anyone who attempts to escape will meet the same fate. They must stay until one of them confesses to the murder of the dead girl, whom they all knew. Ames tries to piece together the facts and discover what happened on that fateful night a year ago. The clock is ticking, and time is running out.
The beginning was a little slow for me, but once the story got going, the pace picked up and it became increasingly difficult to put down. I liked Ames as a protagonist. I was surprised at first that the other teens, who were a bit older than her, let her take charge of the investigation at the voice's insistence, but understood as I got to know her. I admired her courage and determination to uncover the truth. She also suffers from panic attacks in confined spaces, which made her feel more relatable and added another layer of tension to an already tense situation.
At first, it seemed like the same old trope of people being locked in a place, but it was anything but. What I particularly enjoyed was that the locked-room setup wasn't just used as a backdrop for a familiar trope. There was an actual mystery to unravel, with the events of the previous year gradually coming to light. The twists and final reveal caught me completely unaware. Several times I thought I knew where the story was going, only to be proven wrong. I was sure the culprits would get away and was ready to be upset over it, and I was pleasantly surprised.
Whilst we don't get an in-depth view of every character, there is enough of their personality to differentiate between them. As it is written in the present tense, the reader experiences the events alongside the characters. The book explores themes of loss, grief, revenge, friendship, and redemption. There is a dash of romance, but it doesn't overshadow the mystery. The Snapchat memories, video fragments, and letters between the chapters enriched the plot. The storytelling created a strong sense of claustrophobia and a creepy atmosphere.
The author has masterfully woven everything together, gradually revealing snippets of information without giving too much away until the end. The final twist left me agog, and I especially liked the buildup of tension. The author is quickly becoming one of my favorite authors, and I look forward to reading more of her books. As you gather, I loved the book and recommend it to fans of locked-room mysteries with a bite. Just a note, as it is a YA, it may be predictable to some. I didn't find it so. Full stars from me!
* Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this arc. All opinions are my own.
* For more info about the book: "Worse Than the Others" by Mackenzie Reed









