"The Woman in Cabin 10" meets "Below Deck". "Let's Not Go Overboard Here" by Erica Hendry is an intriguing mystery centering on a pop culture aficionado protagonist who finds herself in a real-time mystery, Agatha Christie style.
Melanie Hoffman is a bisexual Jewish attorney in her 30s who hasn’t overcome—or made peace with—her best friend's death. The two belonged to what they called the "Broken Brain" club: people who can spew pop culture references at the drop of a pin. When her HR director forces her to take a mandatory vacation, she accepts her law school best friend Vish's invitation to be his plus one on a yacht trip in Greece, chartered by his tech company.
When one of Vish's colleagues disappears, Mel suspects foul play. With the help of her friends—the “Sherlock Hoes” group—she starts digging. After all, it is easier to investigate a stranger's case than deal with her own grief. The trouble is that no one on the yacht takes her seriously, thinking she has lost her mind—and her unhinged behavior doesn't help. The clock is ticking, and Mel must uncover what happened to Freya before it runs out.
This is a story of grief, friendships, found family, and healing. I had a hard time getting into it at first—the slow pace and constant self-reflection made it feel dragging. The plot also gets bogged down at times with the many pop culture references. However, once I got past that, it really picked up, and I ended up enjoying it. I didn’t recognize some of the references, but enough landed for me to enjoy the story. I liked the flashbacks, which helped highlight the bond between Mel and her late friend.
Some of the secondary characters weren’t likable, and a few fell flat. Mel could be really annoying—her over-the-top behavior and relentless internal dialogue, combined with her disregard for others, made her exhausting to follow. She went overboard with her investigation, even hurting her best friend in the process. So consumed by grief, she didn’t notice the impact of her actions on those around her. I also couldn’t understand why her “Sherlock Hoes” group encouraged her to invade privacy and break legal lines—and she’s a lawyer, for God’s sake!
I did enjoy the humor, wit, and banter with her friends. The depiction of grief was well done, and I could relate to her. She grew on me, and I ended up rooting for her. The plot, twists, and ending made me rate this 4 out of 5 stars. By the end of the third part, my jaw literally dropped—I had no clue that twist was coming! What starts as a seemingly simple mystery turns into something much bigger than I expected. It is a unique tale, and once you get used to the writing, you’ll likely enjoy it.
* Thank you NetGalley and (publisher) for the opportunity to read this arc. All opinions are my own.
* For more info about the book: "Let's Not Go Overboard Here" by Erica Hendry









